Man I can’t wait to go to my next indie show and see some shortform
This is clearly written by someone who has been having trouble navigating the indie scene and the world of neophyte performers. A lot of shows exist just to give young performers (of improv, stand-up, etc) experience on stage and are not necessarily meant for the general public. This is definitely true in New York (and we are very thankful for the existence of those shows).
Also, in general, I have found that stand-up and improv don’t mix well - they are just two different beasts (and the stand-up usually ends up making fun of the improv). Mixing long, short, and sketch, etc., requires a deft host with good pacing.
Point is, this guy’s a total whiny loser who doesn’t know what he’s talking about.
This is so tough! (Re: the three teams. Living the lie is a given.)
In an article from January 2011 Time Out Comedy writer Jason A. Heidemann wrote:
Performed in the hands of pros like TJ & Dave, long-form improv can be spine-tingling, not to mention revelatory. But it requires patience and careful listening. Too often, three long-form troupes will be booked back-to-back-to-back and it’s just too much (especially if one or more groups has an off night). Instead, give us one or two groups and mix the rest of the night up with some stand-up or short form. On behalf of my friends who’ve sworn off improv, I’m begging you.
What do you think? Are 3 teams performing long form to much? Is my life a lie?
